Skip to content
Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

Primary Menu Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

  • Home
  • Newswires
  • Politics & Society
  • The New Feudals
  • World View
  • Arts And Aesthetics
  • For The Record
  • About Us
  • Featured

Lawyer Prashant Bhushan’s Apology Deadline Ends Today

Aug 24, 2020 | Pratirodh Bureau

FILE PHOTO: Prashant Bhushan speaks with the media outside the Supreme Court in New Delhi on April 19, 2018

One of India’s most prominent lawyers faces a Monday deadline to apologise to the Supreme Court or risk jail in a case testing the judiciary’s openness to criticism and sparking a debate on freedom of speech in the world’s largest democracy.

Prashant Bhushan, 63, was found guilty of criminal contempt for attempting “to scandalize the entire institution” with Twitter posts depicting the chief justice on a motorcycle while the court’s work was curtailed due to the COVID-19 pandemic, and criticising previous top judges.

The top court on Thursday ordered Bhushan, who has championed public interest litigation, to issue an “unconditional apology” by Monday. He faces up to six months in jail or a fine of Rs 2,000 or both.

“Any apology would be insincere,” Bhushan told Reuters, declining to comment further as the matter is before the court.

He told the court in a statement on Thursday that he would “cheerfully submit to any penalty” over the two June tweets, which he said “represented my bonafide beliefs, the expression of which must be permissible in any democracy.”

If Bhushan apologises, the court has said it would hold a hearing on Tuesday. It was not clear when or how the court would respond if he does not apologise.

Regardless of the outcome, Bhushan’s case is putting the Supreme Court, one of India’s most respected institutions, on trial, testing how much judges may be openly criticised in a society known for free-wheeling debate.

Freedom of speech is a fundamental right in India and highly contentious. The top court often hears cases where litigants argue their right to express themselves is being infringed.

Some lawyers and media editorials support Bhushan, saying the court is being too harsh, arguing that his tweets amounted to legally protected criticism.

“A bar silenced under the threat of contempt will undermine the independence and ultimately the strength of the court,” more than 2,400 Indian lawyers wrote in an online petition.

Others criticised Bhushan, who has 1.7 million Twitter followers.

“A lawyer is not above the law, nobody is,” said Satyadarshi Sanjay, a lawyer who signed an open letter by more than 100 people, including former judges, who support the court’s decision.

TWO TWEETS

Judges too sometimes chastise the judiciary. In 2018, four sitting Supreme Court justices held a rare press conference criticising the court’s distribution of cases to judges and raising concerns about judicial appointments.

The Supreme Court, in its 108-page order in Bhushan’s case, noted it is “required to be magnanimous” to criticism – though it said “such magnanimity cannot be stretched”.

In his first tweet, Bhushan posted a viral photo of Chief Justice S.A. Bobde astride a Harley-Davidson. He wrote Bobde was sitting on a Rs 5 million bike without a mask or a helmet when citizens were being denied justice as the court was in lockdown.

The Supreme Court ruled the tweet was “patently false” and had the “tendency to shake the confidence of the public”, as the court was hearing matters even during the coronavirus shutdown.

In the other tweet, Bhushan wrote that when historians look at how democracy has been destroyed in India in the past six years, they will mark the role of the court and the past four top justices.

That tweet “has the effect of destabilising the very foundation of this important pillar of the Indian democracy” and “directly affronts the majesty of law”, the court said.

Both of Bhushan’s tweets have been suspended by Twitter.

Tags: “unconditional apology”, Chief Justice S A Bobde, coronavirus shutdown, criminal contempt, freedom of speech, Prashant Bhushan, Pratirodh, Supreme Court, Twitter Posts

Continue Reading

Previous NZ Gunman “Intended To Kill As Many People As He Could”
Next Sonia Gandhi Offers To Resign After Dissent Letter

More Stories

  • Featured

As Migrants Flee Cities, Concerns About Covid Surge In Villages

15 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Not Even Fear Of Covid Can Disrupt Protest, Say Agitating Farmers

15 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

US Defends Navy Ship’s Navigational Rights Inside India’s EEZ

19 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau

Recent Posts

  • As Migrants Flee Cities, Concerns About Covid Surge In Villages
  • Not Even Fear Of Covid Can Disrupt Protest, Say Agitating Farmers
  • US Defends Navy Ship’s Navigational Rights Inside India’s EEZ
  • George Floyd Autopsy: Doctor Stands By Homicide Conclusion
  • Gyanvapi Mosque: UP Waqf Board To Challenge ASI Survey Order
  • Police Clamp Curbs On Media Coverage Of Kashmir Gunbattles
  • Govt. To Review Covid Vaccines After Blood Clot Warning
  • ‘Climate Change, Rich-Poor Gap, Conflict Likely To Grow’
  • ‘Onus Is On Men’: Imran’s Ex-Wife On His ‘Vulgarity’ Rape Remark
  • Rallies, Religious Gatherings Aggravate Worst Covid Surge
  • Compensate Farmers For Crop Damage By Animals: Tikait
  • Myanmar Activists Hold Shoe Protests, Another Celebrity Held
  • 7 Arrested After Climate Protesters Target Barclays London HQ
  • Foundation Laid For ‘Memorial’ To Farmers Who Died During Protests
  • UK Variant Found In 80% Of Covid Cases In Punjab: Health Minister
  • Amnesty International Says Russia May Be Slowly Killing Navalny
  • “Time Has Come”: Tikait Warns Of Farmers’ Tractor Rally In Gujarat
  • Next Four Weeks ‘Very, Very Critical’ In Covid Battle: Health Official
  • Anti-Maoist Ops Stepped Up After 22 Police Killed In Ambush
  • Climate Change Shrinks Marine Life Richness Near Equator: Study

Search

Main Links

  • Home
  • Newswires
  • Politics & Society
  • The New Feudals
  • World View
  • Arts And Aesthetics
  • For The Record
  • About Us

Related Stroy

  • Featured

As Migrants Flee Cities, Concerns About Covid Surge In Villages

15 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Not Even Fear Of Covid Can Disrupt Protest, Say Agitating Farmers

15 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

US Defends Navy Ship’s Navigational Rights Inside India’s EEZ

19 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

George Floyd Autopsy: Doctor Stands By Homicide Conclusion

20 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Gyanvapi Mosque: UP Waqf Board To Challenge ASI Survey Order

1 day ago Pratirodh Bureau

Recent Posts

  • As Migrants Flee Cities, Concerns About Covid Surge In Villages
  • Not Even Fear Of Covid Can Disrupt Protest, Say Agitating Farmers
  • US Defends Navy Ship’s Navigational Rights Inside India’s EEZ
  • George Floyd Autopsy: Doctor Stands By Homicide Conclusion
  • Gyanvapi Mosque: UP Waqf Board To Challenge ASI Survey Order
Copyright © All rights reserved. | CoverNews by AF themes.