Skip to content
Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

Primary Menu Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

  • Home
  • Newswires
  • Politics & Society
  • The New Feudals
  • World View
  • Arts And Aesthetics
  • For The Record
  • About Us
  • Featured

Advertising Bigotry And All That Implies

Oct 29, 2021 | Shalini Rai

The Dabur ad was withdrawn after Madhya Pradesh Home Minister Narottam Mishra criticised it for showing “objectionable content” and said that legal steps would be taken if the advertisement was not withdrawn. “Today, they are showing two women celebrating Karva Chauth. Tomorrow, they will come up with an advertisement that shows two men getting married. We cannot allow anyone to show such objectionable content,” Mishra told reporters in Bhopal

Recently, several advertisements have been making headlines for all the wrong reasons. The ensuing brouhaha — over a missing ‘bindi’ in one ad and prominently visible cleavage in another — has made it clear that we are entering a minefield of political correctness which is littered with generous amounts of obscure, old-fashioned bigotry.

Let’s start with the most recent ad that raised some people’s hackles. The Dabur ad showed a lesbian couple celebrating the festival of Karwa Chauth. But it was later withdrawn and an apology tendered by Dabur to those ‘offended’ by the content of the ad, especially after Madhya Pradesh Home Minister Narottam Mishra criticised it for showing “objectionable content” and said that legal steps would be taken if the advertisement was not withdrawn. “Today, they are showing two women celebrating Karva Chauth. Tomorrow, they will come up with an advertisement that shows two men getting married. We cannot allow anyone to show such objectionable content,” Mishra told reporters at a press conference in Bhopal on the morning of October 25.

“Fem’s Karwachauth campaign has been withdrawn from all social media handles and we unconditionally apologise for unintentionally hurting people’s sentiments,” Dabur India said in a statement released on its official Twitter handle.

The fact is that same-sex marriages are still not possible in India despite the Supreme Court decriminalising consensual homosexual acts and gay couples seeking a declaration to recognise them under the Hindu Marriage Act (HMA) and Special Marriage Act (SMA). Therefore, the MP Home Minister could say things like, “Today, they are showing two women celebrating Karva Chauth. Tomorrow, they will…. show… two men getting married.”

The second ad campaign which seems to have stirred a hornet’s nest is that showing a plus-size model with a prominent cleavage wearing a ‘mangalsutra’. This ad by the upscale clothing and accessories brand Sabyasachi has miffed people who are comparing the image in question with a B-grade Bollywood film. No mention is made of the fact that the depiction of the human body and consequently, its various parts in their natural state, does not constitute ‘vulgarity’ or ‘obscenity’. The offending of some ‘sensibilities’ in this case has trumped all arguments in support of the aesthetics of the ad campaign.

Fab India recently launched a clothing collection titled ‘Jashn-e-Riwaaz’ (celebration of tradition), ahead of the festive season but it was variously condemned as ‘damaging the Hindu festival of Diwali’ and attempting the ‘Abrahamisation of Hindu festivals’. Soon, the hashtag #BoycottFabIndia began trending on social media and needless to say, FabIndia removed the tweet with the ‘offending’ images and pulled the ad.

The fourth ad in question is that featuring Alia Bhatt for the clothing brand ‘Manyavar’, in which she questions the ‘Kanyadaan’ ritual — a staple of Hindu weddings — and wonders if daughters are ‘property’ to be given away (as ‘daan’). Apparently, this narrative too created quite a flutter among netizens and expectedly the hashtag #BoycottManyavar started to trend on social media. Consequently, this ad too was withdrawn and Alia Bhatt and the brand itself came in for much criticism.

#NoBindiNoBusiness has been making waves on social media in the last few days and for all the wrong reasons. The concerned ad shows a Tanishq model with no ‘bindi’ on her forehead and with what some believe is ‘an expression fit for a funeral’, under its ‘Utsaah’ collection. After the online hullabaloo on the same lines as all the other four ads mentioned above, Tanishq has re-launched its campaign, this time with a model wearing both a ‘bindi’ and a smile, standing beside a traditional brass lamp.

The cumulative effect of the publication and subsequent withdrawal of these advertisements shows both the growing clout of netizens in dictating consumer choices and a rising ‘intolerance’ of divergent depictions of traditional mores and rituals, however well-meaning they might start out as.

This manifests itself in the labelling of the Sabyasachi plus-size model as ‘obscene’ while wearing the ‘sacred mangalsutra’. Someone needs to ask why it is ok for the ‘mangalsutra’ to be considered ‘sacred’ but the treatment of your wife post-marriage (in cases of domestic violence) is not. Even the well-meaning concept of ‘Kanyamaan’, sought to be introduced instead of ‘Kanyadaan’, seems to have backfired, with the Twiterrati attributing all kinds of nefarious intentions to what is a well-intended revision of last-century rituals.

As far as FabIndia’s ‘Jashn-e-Riwaaz’ is concerned, the vitriol poured on the eponymous term itself is surprising, with parodies of the same making their way onto social media and eliciting scores of likes and supportive comments. The same holds true for the #NoBindiNoBusiness online campaign, which has seen jewellers in Maharashtra give in and re-launch ads with bindi-wearing models, in clear capitulation to the online brigade which started the hashtag.

However, the most damaging has been the aftermath of the pulling of Dabur’s ad showing a lesbian couple celebrating Karwa Chauth. What no one seems to notice or take umbrage to is the fact that the ritual of Karwa Chauth itself is a manifestation of a deeply-patriarchal society and its regressive traditions, where a woman has to fast for the health and well being of her husband (with the husband doing nothing complementary for his wife and partner in life). The Dabur ad went the whole hog and stuck its neck out by depicting such a welcome change in the ritualistic status quo. But instead of being greeted wholesomely and praised for its courage to shoot such an ad, it has been castigated with impunity. This is even more disturbing since the apex court of the country has already decriminalised consensual homosexual acts.

The kerfuffle over the content, depiction and revisionism attempted in the above-mentioned ad campaigns is deceptively politically-correct. After all, why would brands who owe their prominence and presence to the continued support and goodwill of their consumers not cater to their demands and attempt to alienate or insult their sensibilities? The moot point is rather complicated.

By naming and shaming, by boycotting and castigating ad campaigns launched by well-established businesses, some consumers might get the impression that they are making necessary ‘course-correction’. However, what they are oblivious to is the majoritarianism inherent in any such campaign of boycott. The nefarious nature of such public mobilisation against a company whose ads offend or insult a section of society may not be immediately discernible. That does not make them any less damaging.

The true resilience of a social system and therefore of a nation, is contingent upon its internal checks and balances. Checks on steering away from majoritarianism and balances ensuring an environment of healthy dissent and disagreement. Given our current trajectory (or flight path), we are on a collision course and do not even seem to realise it.

 

Tags: #NoBindiNoBusiness, Alia Bhatt Kanyadaan ad, Dabur Karwa Chauth ad, Dabur lesbian ad, FabIndia 'Jashn-e-Riwaaz' ad, political correctness, Pratirodh, Sabyasachi 'mangalsutra' ad

Continue Reading

Previous Only 4 Pacific Island Nations To Attend COP26
Next Tensions Rise In Tripura After Attacks Against Minorities

More Stories

  • Featured

How India’s Migrant Labour Struggles During Times Of Crisis

25 mins ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Farms Turn Femme But Women Still Plough Through Power Centres

2 hours ago Shalini
  • Featured

PM Must Tell All-Party Meeting What He Told US President Trump: Congress

18 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau

Recent Posts

  • How India’s Migrant Labour Struggles During Times Of Crisis
  • Farms Turn Femme But Women Still Plough Through Power Centres
  • PM Must Tell All-Party Meeting What He Told US President Trump: Congress
  • Iran-Israel ‘Threshold War’ Has Rewritten Rules Of Nuclear Escalation
  • Children’s Literature Joins The Conversation On Climate Change
  • Instead Of ‘Achhe Din’, Days Of Debt Arrived: Cong’s Dig At Modi Govt
  • A Song Of Rock And Ice
  • Access & Benefit Sharing Regulations Impinge On Rights Of Local Communities
  • Making Cuts In Implementation Of MGNREGA A Crime Against Constitution
  • Tiger Death Highlights Strained Human-Wildlife Interactions In Assam
  • Scientists And Monks Perform Last Rites For A Himalayan Glacier
  • Bihar Yearning For Change But The Election Is Wide Open
  • Shipwreck Spills Oil, Plastic & Legal Loopholes
  • As India’s Groundwater Runs Dry, The Calls For Reform Grow
  • ‘US Invite To Pak Army Chief Huge Diplomatic Setback For India’
  • Politics Based On Grievance Has A Long And Violent History In America
  • How Birds Are Taking A Hit From Microplastics Contamination
  • Kharge Reviews 11 Yrs Of NDA Govt, Says PM Made 33 Mistakes
  • Upholding The Law, SC Halts Amnesties For EIA Violators, Jolts Industry
  • Using Indian Languages When Reporting About The Environment

Search

Main Links

  • Home
  • Newswires
  • Politics & Society
  • The New Feudals
  • World View
  • Arts And Aesthetics
  • For The Record
  • About Us

Related Stroy

  • Featured

How India’s Migrant Labour Struggles During Times Of Crisis

25 mins ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Farms Turn Femme But Women Still Plough Through Power Centres

2 hours ago Shalini
  • Featured

PM Must Tell All-Party Meeting What He Told US President Trump: Congress

18 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Iran-Israel ‘Threshold War’ Has Rewritten Rules Of Nuclear Escalation

1 day ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Children’s Literature Joins The Conversation On Climate Change

1 day ago Pratirodh Bureau

Recent Posts

  • How India’s Migrant Labour Struggles During Times Of Crisis
  • Farms Turn Femme But Women Still Plough Through Power Centres
  • PM Must Tell All-Party Meeting What He Told US President Trump: Congress
  • Iran-Israel ‘Threshold War’ Has Rewritten Rules Of Nuclear Escalation
  • Children’s Literature Joins The Conversation On Climate Change
Copyright © All rights reserved. | CoverNews by AF themes.