Skip to content
Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

Primary Menu Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

Hindi News, हिंदी समाचार, Samachar, Breaking News, Latest Khabar – Pratirodh

  • Home
  • Newswires
  • Politics & Society
  • The New Feudals
  • World View
  • Arts And Aesthetics
  • For The Record
  • About Us
  • Featured

A furore over a song…

Sep 14, 2011 | Highlander

The controversy over singing Vande Matram has kept on raging time and again and I am compelled to travel back in time and revisit an incidence that places the whole thing in a different and much more humane perspective.

 
It was in 2005, the centenary year of the celebrated song, that the controversy over its universal rendition in the country was on. The union Human Resource Development ministry under Arjun Singh had called for the singing of the song by everyone and the Muslims were yet again in the docks being asked to prove their patriotism and nationalism by publicly singing the song, a thing which a section of the Muslims was not ready for.
 
As it was I was at that time reporting from the ‘communal cauldron’ of Ahmedabad that was trying to breathe freely after the ghastly Godhra and post Godhra events of 2002. in order to escape media debate, the Narendra Modi led BJP government in the state had come out with an order asking the institutions and the public to sing the song without making it clear whether the entire song was to be sung or just a portion of it.
 
Having been at the receiving end, a section of the Muslims decided to publicly sing a portion of the song. They decided not to sing that portion to which the clergy was opposed and claimed that singing this portion would amount to idolatry.
 
Having decided to take the certificate in nationalism and patriotism, this group of Muslims got down to erecting a stage in the area of Juhapura, which has probably emerged as one of the biggest Muslim ghettoes in the entire South Asia. They also invited the media for the event. Reporting for a foreign media organization at that point of time, I decided to cover the event which was both topical and which also conveyed a lot through the nuances.
 
The biggest problem for the organizers turned out to be gathering volunteers to sing the song. Hence came the incentive in the form of a skull cap. I had never even imagined that to sing Vande Matram, one required a skull cap or any cap for that matter. The next problem was to hand over a printout of the portion of the song to be sung to everyone present since no one, including me, knew the song beyond its first stanza by heart.
 
Somehow, a group of about 100 Muslims gathered at the venue on the given day at the given time amidst a scramble for possessing the cap. The singing started. The first stanza went off fine. It was at this time point, when the second stanza was to be sung, that a large number of volunteers realized that in the scramble for possessing the incentive of a cap, they had lost the print out of the song. I could not help laughing along with a Muslim friend of mine while looking at a large number of volunteers shouting to each other in order to get a print out of the song.
 
It was at that point that I realized the state has much to deliver to its masses, particularly the marginalized before such things can be made an issue of. The primary issue before the nation continues to be not whether to publicly sing a song or not but the issues still alive and to de addressed continue to be that of hunger, employment, poverty, education and above all—the inclusive development.

Continue Reading

Previous The Rise and Fall of Reddys; A lesson for the political parties
Next Activists Demand Immediate Release of Lingaram

More Stories

  • Featured

Farmers Allege Conspiracy To Kill 4 Of Them During Tractor Rally

10 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Tree Planting Efforts Push Out Pastoralists In The Himalayas

10 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

A Year After Wuhan Lockdown, A World Still Deep In Crisis

18 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau

Recent Posts

  • Farmers Allege Conspiracy To Kill 4 Of Them During Tractor Rally
  • Tree Planting Efforts Push Out Pastoralists In The Himalayas
  • A Year After Wuhan Lockdown, A World Still Deep In Crisis
  • Farmers To Step Up Protests After Rejecting Govt Offer
  • Farm Laws: Govt Offers Suspension, Farmers Want Repeal
  • BJP Members Amplify False Claim About Microchip In Vaccine
  • India’s Vac Diplomacy In South Asia Pushes Back Against China
  • ‘Your Land’? Native Americans Question Inaugural Song
  • 5 Killed In Blaze At Serum Institute Of India
  • Nepal To Turn Everest Trash Into Art To Highlight Garbage Blight
  • Biden Rolls Back Trump Policies On Health, Climate, Wall, Muslims
  • Govt Offers To Suspend Implementation Of Farm Laws
  • Massive Security Phalanx In Place To Shield Biden Inauguration
  • A Lotus, Not A Chinese Dragon: Gujarat Changes Name Of Fruit
  • “We’ve Got A Lot Of Work To Do. It’s Not Going To Be Easy”
  • Govt. Urges Frontline Workers Not To Refuse Vax As Targets Missed
  • Estonian Firm Seeks Finance From Forests
  • China, WHO Could Have Acted More Quickly: Probe Panel
  • ‘Advisable To Not Take Vaccine If’: Covaxin Factsheet
  • Opp Seeks Probe Into Security Leak After Goswami’s Messages Emerge

Search

Main Links

  • Home
  • Newswires
  • Politics & Society
  • The New Feudals
  • World View
  • Arts And Aesthetics
  • For The Record
  • About Us

Related Stroy

  • Featured

Farmers Allege Conspiracy To Kill 4 Of Them During Tractor Rally

10 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Tree Planting Efforts Push Out Pastoralists In The Himalayas

10 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

A Year After Wuhan Lockdown, A World Still Deep In Crisis

18 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Farmers To Step Up Protests After Rejecting Govt Offer

18 hours ago Pratirodh Bureau
  • Featured

Farm Laws: Govt Offers Suspension, Farmers Want Repeal

1 day ago Pratirodh Bureau

Recent Posts

  • Farmers Allege Conspiracy To Kill 4 Of Them During Tractor Rally
  • Tree Planting Efforts Push Out Pastoralists In The Himalayas
  • A Year After Wuhan Lockdown, A World Still Deep In Crisis
  • Farmers To Step Up Protests After Rejecting Govt Offer
  • Farm Laws: Govt Offers Suspension, Farmers Want Repeal
Copyright © All rights reserved. | CoverNews by AF themes.